- Area
- Nohoch Nah Chich
- Cave system
- Aktun-Hu
Location#
Loading address…
- 20.31519, -87.43128
Access#
Access
Signs in English and Spanish warn cave divers not to enter the Hoyo Negro area.
A deep pit in the Aktun Hu section of Sistema Sac Actun. Alex Alvarez, Franco Attolini and Alberto Nava (Proyecto Espeleológico de Tulum, Global Underwater Explorers) explored it in March 2008. It holds the bones of Ice Age animals - among them a mastodon, at about 60 m - and the skeleton of a teenage girl, named Naia, found at about 43 m: one of the oldest and most complete human skeletons found in the Americas (National Geographic, 2011 and 2014).
Photos2#
Videos#
No videos yet.
Survey maps15#
Further reading14#
- Late Pleistocene Human Skeleton and mtDNA Link Paleoamericans and Modern Native Americans
James C. Chatters, Douglas J. Kennett, Yemane Asmerom et al. · 2014 · science.org
This Science paper presents Naia, a nearly complete human skeleton with an intact skull, found together with the bones of extinct Ice Age animals in Hoyo Negro, a deep flooded pit in the Sac Actun cave system on the Caribbean coast of the Yucatán. Unusually for such an old find, her remains still held usable DNA. The team dated the skeleton to between about 13,000 and 12,000 calendar years ago. Her skull and face have the shape seen in the earliest Americans, often called Paleoamericans, which differ from those of living Native Americans and had led some researchers to propose a separate origin for them. Her mitochondrial DNA, however, belongs to haplogroup D1, a lineage of Beringian origin that is still carried by Native Americans today. The authors conclude that the contrast between the first Americans and later Native Americans most likely came from evolution within the Americas rather than from two separate ancestral groups. For divers, it is the founding study of why Hoyo Negro, deep inside a flooded cave, matters so much to the story of the first people in the Americas.
- Reconstructing water level in Hoyo Negro, Quintana Roo, Mexico, implications for early Paleoamerican and faunal access
Shawn V. Collins, Eduard G. Reinhardt, Dominique Rissolo et al. · 2015 · sciencedirect.com
Hoyo Negro is a deep chamber of the Sac Actun system where the human skeleton known as Naia, dated to 12,000 to 13,000 years ago, lies with extinct megafauna roughly 40 to 43 m below present sea level. This study asks when the pit and the passages leading to it flooded, and therefore when people and animals could still walk in. The team took twelve sediment cores in the connecting tunnels and in the Ich Balam and Oasis cenotes, and sorted the deposits into four kinds: bat guano with seeds, lime mud, calcite rafts, and organic matter mixed with calcite rafts, told apart by their microfossils (ostracods, foraminifera, testate amoebae). Radiocarbon dates on these underwater layers, read against profiles of the cave floor and ceiling, show that the bottom of the pit was flooded by at least 9,850 years ago and that the chamber was cut off from dry access around 8,100 years ago. Water kept rising until about 6,000 years ago, drowning the passages and the cenote entrances. Post-glacial sea-level rise and ceiling height together decided where air pockets remained and where floating debris and bat material settled.
- Hoyo Negro: The Formation and Transformation of a Submerged Late Pleistocene Cave Site in Quintana Roo, Mexico
Dominique Rissolo, James C. Chatters, Alberto E. Nava Blank et al. · 2018 · core.tdar.org
This conference paper, given at the 2018 meeting of the Society for Historical Archaeology in New Orleans, outlines how the interdisciplinary Hoyo Negro Project is working out how the site came to be and how it changed over thousands of years. Hoyo Negro is a deep flooded pit in the Sac Actun cave system of Quintana Roo, and like other submerged caves of the region it holds Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene deposits in exceptional condition, a window on life on the Yucatán Peninsula as the last glacial period ended. Besides the continuing studies of the human skeleton and of the many Pleistocene animal and plant remains, the team has examined several environmental indicators that record the different ways material was laid down in the cave and how conditions shifted over time. The authors point out that deep anchialine caves preserve bones, plant remains and sediments remarkably well, but that dating them with radiometric methods is hard, a problem their research is still tackling.
- Recent Analyses of the Faunal Assemblage from the Submerged Cave Site of Hoyo Negro: Implications for Late Pleistocene Human Ecology Research on the Yucatan Peninsula
Dominique Rissolo, James C. Chatters, Joaquín Arroyo-Cabrales et al. · 2016 · core.tdar.org
This 2016 conference paper reviews the animal bones of Hoyo Negro, the submerged pit in the Sac Actun cave system that also holds a nearly complete Late Pleistocene human skeleton. The site preserves a varied collection of both extinct and still-living Yucatán species in very good condition, and recent fieldwork concentrated on recording them in place, sampling them and bringing selected specimens to the surface for study. The authors single out bears of the genus Tremarctos, a megalonychid ground sloth that had not yet been named (it was described in 2017 as Nohochichak xibalbahkah), cougars, and an animal that may be a dog-like canid. Because cougars vanished from North America for much of the Pleistocene and only returned north at the end of the last glaciation, the team wants to learn when the Hoyo Negro cats died and how they relate to North and South American populations. The possible dog seems to be more than 9,600 years old, which would place it among the earliest domestic dogs in the Americas. Together these animals describe the world the first people of the peninsula lived in.
- Oral health and diet of a young Late Pleistocene woman from Quintana Roo, Mexico
Andrea Cucina, José Rubén Herrera-Atoche, James C. Chatters · 2019 · onlinelibrary.wiley.com
This study looks at the teeth of Naia, the young woman whose skeleton lies at the bottom of Hoyo Negro, a submerged natural trap in the Sac Actun cave system where she was found alongside many extinct megafauna. She was 15 to 17 years old and lived at the very end of the Pleistocene, and her skull kept 28 teeth in excellent condition. The authors checked them for cavities, gum disease, wear and bite problems. Naia had many cavities and an aggressive periodontal disease that endangered all her teeth, especially the incisors. Her teeth were barely worn for a hunter-gatherer, which goes with a strongly receding lower jaw and weak chewing forces. Compared with other early North American individuals older than 11,000 years, mostly women, she shows the most cavities, close to the earliest South Americans, and one of the least worn sets of teeth; the others all wore their front teeth quickly by using them as tools. The authors infer that her food was soft and, at least in some seasons, rich in carbohydrates, though that does not rule out a diet with plenty of meat.
- The Life of the Adolescent Paleoindian Female from Hoyo Negro, Quintana Roo, Mexico
James C. Chatters, Vera Tiesler, Andrea Cucina et al. · 2017 · core.tdar.org
Cave divers found the remains of a teenage girl in 2007 in a vast flooded chamber of the Sac Actun cave system, the pit known as Hoyo Negro. For years she could only be studied from photographs, photo-based 3D models and a few small samples; this 2017 conference paper reports on her skeleton after it was brought up from the cave, conserved and analysed. Few women from the late Pleistocene are known in the Americas, and her skeleton is unusually complete and well preserved. Naia, as she is called, died between 15 and 17 years of age, had a healed spiral fracture of the forearm that may point to rough treatment, and went through a period of severe metabolic stress in the months before her death. X-rays and close examination show many regular growth-arrest lines in her long bones, cavities, enamel defects, a poor bite, crowded teeth and a late-developing lower jaw, signs that she had trouble getting enough protein steadily. Dated to 13,000 to 12,000 calibrated years before present, she joins the handful of early women whose remains suggest short and hard lives.
- Ancient remains and the first peopling of the Americas: Reassessing the Hoyo Negro skull
Soledad de Azevedo, María Cátira Bortolini, Sandro L. Bonatto et al. · 2015 · onlinelibrary.wiley.com
The skull of the roughly 12,500-year-old skeleton from Hoyo Negro, the flooded pit in the Sac Actun system on the Yucatán coast, had been described by its discoverers as belonging to the Paleoamericans, the earliest Americans whose skull shape differs from that of modern Native Americans. That conclusion rested on a description of the skull (catalogued HN5/48). In this reply, a team of geneticists and morphologists measured the skull's shape from the images published in the original article, using geometric morphometrics, and compared it with ancient and modern skulls from Asia and the Americas. In a principal component analysis the Hoyo Negro skull falls in an area shared by Paleoamericans and some modern Native Americans, but discriminant analyses place it closer to a modern Native American sample. The authors read this as support for their model in which the first population to reach the New World was already very variable in its physical traits. They also argue that classifications should be tested formally before they are used to build settlement scenarios. It is a useful counterpoint for anyone following the debate around the Hoyo Negro finds.
- Novel application of 3D documentation techniques at a submerged Late Pleistocene cave site in Quintana Roo, Mexico
Dominique Rissolo, Alberto Nava Blank, Vid Petrovic et al. · 2015 · ieeexplore.ieee.org
Hoyo Negro is a flooded cave site near the east coast of the Yucatán Peninsula that holds a varied collection of fossils of extinct megafauna and an almost complete human skeleton. Because the site is remote and very few researchers can reach it, recording it fully in three dimensions calls for specialised techniques. This 2015 conference paper presents how the Hoyo Negro underwater archaeology project of Mexico's Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia (INAH), working with the Center of Interdisciplinary Science for Art, Architecture, and Archaeology at the University of California, San Diego, is developing advanced methods for structure-from-motion photogrammetry, building 3D models from many overlapping photographs, and for visualising underwater heritage sites. The aim is a complete three-dimensional record of the site and everything in it. For cave divers it shows how the deep pit and its bones are being documented in place, and why photo surveys made by divers are central to the science done at the site.
- A potential Late Pleistocene human skeleton in Hoyo Negro, a submerged cave site in Quintana Roo, Mexico
James C. Chatters, Dominique Rissolo, Pilar Luna Erreguerena et al. · 2012 · web.archive.org
This 2012 poster gave the first scientific report of a human skeleton in Hoyo Negro, a pit about 60 m deep at the end of a submerged tunnel of the Aktun Hu cave system. Cave explorers working there in 2007 and 2010 also found what the authors describe as fire pits in the tunnel floor, rope marks on the rim of the pit, and the skeleton of a proboscidean (an elephant relative) a few metres from the human. The tunnel floor lies below sea level, the pit is 180 m upstream of the nearest opening, and the human and animal bones look alike, so the team suspected both date to the late Pleistocene. From underwater video and high-resolution photographs they inventoried a complete skull and jaw, vertebrae, ribs, one hip bone and both arms, all in excellent condition. Tooth and bone development show a female who died between 16 and 18 years of age, and her skull has the long braincase and projecting face typical of Paleoamerican women. The team then planned minimal sampling and 2D and 3D imaging in place to date her and gather more data.
- Histomorphology and Metabolic History of a Submerged Pleistocene Skeleton from the Cenote of Hoyo Negro, Tulum, Quintana Roo, Mexico
Julio Chi, James C. Chatters, Andrea Cucina et al. · 2015 · core.tdar.org
This 2015 conference paper studies the microscopic structure of the ribs of the teenage girl found in the flooded cenote of Hoyo Negro near Tulum, whose partly preserved skeleton is among the oldest securely dated human remains in the Americas. Her bones had already been judged, by eye, to belong to someone who died in her mid teens. The researchers cut a thin section from the middle of her twelfth rib, without decalcifying it, and measured bone density, signs of bone formation, the area of cortical and total bone, and the lines that mark interruptions in growth. They compared it with matching rib sections from a group of women from the Yucatán Peninsula. The goal is to learn how well the bone tissue survived underwater and what it says about her metabolism and living conditions. The work was funded by INAH's underwater archaeology department and carried out at the Universidad Autónoma de Yucatán in Mérida.
- General Taphonomy and Diagenesis of a Submerged Pleistocene Skeleton from the Cenote of Hoyo Negro, Tulum, Quintana Roo, Mexico: Preliminary Results
Patricia Quintana, Vera Tiesler, Diana Arano et al. · 2015 · core.tdar.org
This 2015 conference paper looks at what thousands of years underwater did to the bones of Naia, the preceramic teenage girl from Hoyo Negro near Tulum, dated to roughly 13,000 to 12,000 years ago. Her skeleton, partly lifted from the cave when the study was made, lay 41 m below sea level in a flooded karst cave. Although it is generally well preserved, the bones are brittle and show damage from age, weathering, changes in salinity and microorganisms, and their outer layer is only loosely attached to the bone beneath. The team wanted to understand the changing conditions after her death, judge whether molecular studies would be possible, and help stabilise the teeth and bones in the medium and long term. They combined visual examination with X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, bone histology and chemical analyses of the surrounding water and sediment. The results show that the bone's mineral has been partly replaced by calcium carbonate minerals from the cave, while the microscopic bone structure is moderately preserved. It explains why remains lying in these caves for millennia are so fragile.
- A new genus of megalonychid ground sloth (Mammalia, Xenarthra) from the late Pleistocene of Quintana Roo, Mexico
H. Gregory McDonald, James C. Chatters, Timothy J. Gaudin · 2017 · tandfonline.com
This paper names a new ground sloth, Nohochichak xibalbahkah, from Hoyo Negro, a chamber of the Sac Actun cave system in Quintana Roo whose flooded pit has yielded many late Pleistocene animals. It belongs to the Megalonychidae, a family of mid-sized ground sloths, and is described as both a new genus and a new species. A phylogenetic analysis places its closest relative in Meizonyx salvadorensis, known from the middle Pleistocene of El Salvador. Together these two are the sister group of Megistonyx and Ahytherium from South America, rather than of the other North American megalonychids, Pliometanastes and Megalonyx. The find shows that more kinds of sloths took part in the Great American Biotic Interchange, the exchange of animals between North and South America after the two continents joined, than had been thought. The authors suggest that much of the interchange's diversity, especially species living only in the warm tropical parts of Central America and Mexico, is still to be discovered, and the flooded caves of the Yucatán are one of the places where it may turn up.
- Yucatán carnivorans shed light on the Great American Biotic Interchange
Blaine W. Schubert, James C. Chatters, Joaquín Arroyo-Cabrales et al. · 2019 · royalsocietypublishing.org
The Great American Biotic Interchange, the movement of animals between North and South America once the Panama land bridge formed, is thought to have happened in four main pulses starting about 2.5 million years ago. Warm, wet climates destroy most fossils in Central America and southeastern Mexico, so this history is poorly known there. Diving exploration of the Yucatán's flooded caves, especially the natural trap of Hoyo Negro in the Sac Actun system, is now uncovering an unusually rich and well-preserved late Pleistocene fauna, with radiometric dates on megafauna ranging from about 38,400 to 12,850 calibrated years before present. Among the extinct species are a short-faced bear, Arctotherium wingei, and a wild dog, Protocyon troglodytes, two genera thought to have lived only in South America. They appear to be large mammals whose ancestors came from the north and that later moved back north across the isthmus, extending their known range by more than 2,000 km. With the varied sloths of the same site, they suggest a more complex history of Middle America's fauna, and the authors link a late interchange pulse, including humans, to landscape changes during the last glaciation.
- Surmounting the problems of radiometric dating in the submerged caves of the Yucatan: the La Mina and Hoyo Negro examples
James C. Chatters · 2021 · gsa.confex.com
This invited 2021 talk at the Geological Society of America meeting explains why dating finds in the Yucatán's flooded caves is so hard, and how the problems were reduced at two sites: the deep natural trap of Hoyo Negro and the prehistoric ochre mines in the upper tunnels of La Mina, on the coast of Quintana Roo. Bone collagen rarely survives in these waters, charcoal and wood float and can drift long after they were deposited, and in the dark the food chain may draw on old carbon from guano or from the limestone itself, so organic material of uncertain origin can give misleading ages. Uranium-thorium dating only works in limited cases and should never be applied to bones or teeth. In the ochre mines, identifying the burned tree species showed the charcoal came from human activity between 12,000 and 10,200 years ago, unlike the forest-fire charcoal of Hoyo Negro. At Hoyo Negro, bone mineral ages were bracketed by overlying charcoal, guano or calcite and checked against post-glacial sea-level rise; animal fossils date from 43,000 to 10,000 years ago, and a steady offset of about 3,200 years supports Naia's age of about 12,900 years.
Exploration history#
1987 · Sac Actun
James G. Coke
Original exploration. Jim and Thomas M. Young later produced and published the original map, documenting 4,330 m of water-filled cave.
1988 · Sac Actun
James G. Coke, Johanna DeGroot, Steve DeCarlo, Richard Ribb, Thomas M. Young, C. Goulet
Explored and surveyed (compass and line survey).
Length 3,110 m; completely underwater.
November 1989 · Sac Actun
James G. Coke
Discovery of the Snake Cenote in downstream Sac Actun.
May 1993 · Sac Actun
Dan Lins
Penetration of the "Twister Restriction"; Dan Lins then led the downstream exploration.
April 11, 1996 · Sac Actun
Sam Meacham, Bil Phillips
Connection from the upstream Calimba section to Paso de los Pozos, through the "Boa Restriction".
December 1996 · Sac Actun
Chuck Stevens, Dan Lins
Discovery of the "Road to Sac", during the 1996 Sistema Naval project (Dan Lins, Mike Madden, Andreas W. Matthes, Chuck Stevens).
May 22, 1997 · Sac Actun
Bil Phillips, Daniel Riordan
Discovery of the "Trap Door" (farthest upstream Sac Actun): 2,306 m of new cave.
1998 · Sac Actun
Daniel Riordan
Exploration of the "Hour Glass" section.
Dates as given on the map: 1998-03 - 1998-04.
March 12, 1998 · Sac Actun
Bil Phillips
Discovery of "Lithium Sunset".
March 13, 1999 · Sac Actun
Dan Lins, Bil Phillips
Connection of Sac Actun and Sistema Naval, bringing Sac Actun to 17,079 m.
Section explorers: Si Bi Beh (Bernd Birnbach, Steve Gerrard, Pablo Diaz, Kate M. Lewis, Bil Phillips, Daniel Riordan), Tum Ben Beh (Bil Phillips, Daniel Riordan), Calimba (J. Gonzales, M. Heusick, Sam Meacham, K. Olsen, Bil Phillips, J. Smith), Lithium Sunset (Bernd Birnbach, Bil Phillips, Daniel Riordan, Christophe Le Maillot, J. Walker), Hour Glass (Bil Phillips, Daniel Riordan, E. Martinez), Historic (H. Ayala, G. Coulet, James G. Coke, Richard Ribb, S. De Carlo, P. Parker, J. De Groot, Thomas M. Young, John Zumrick), Siphon (James G. Coke, E. Fiorelli, Woody Jasper, Dan Lins, B. Messersmith, Bil Phillips, C. Pyle, Andreas W. Matthes, J. Walker), Naval (B. Gavin, Hilario Hiler, G. Irvine, Dan Lins, Mike Madden, Andreas W. Matthes, Chuck Stevens).
2007 · Aktun-Hu
Alex Alvarez, Franco Attolini, Alberto Nava, Devin MacKenzie, Susan Bird, Luca Maghelli, Gianmario Roca
Survey ("Topografiado por").
8,660 m of passage.
Thanks to Alejandro, Maurico, Alfredo for help during the Rancho Tamakas exploration.
2007 · Sac Actun
Connection of the Nohoch Kin-Muul Ha and Nohoch Nah Chich regions ("2007 Connection"): 154,783 m, depth 72 m.
November 2009 · Aktun-Hu
Alex Alvarez, Franco Attolini, Alberto Nava, Christophe Le Maillot, Fred Devos, Devin MacKenzie, Daniel Riordan, Susan Bird
Fenomeno Cave (Aktun-Hu system), explored and surveyed.
2011–2012 · Aktun-Hu
Alex Alvarez, Franco Attolini, Alberto Nava, Roberto Chavez, Gideon Liew, Jacob Mellor, Sam Meacham, Susan Bird, Christophe Le Maillot, Olmo Torres-Talamante
Survey with depth computer, compass, ScubaPro sonar, tape and knotted line.
Distance surveyed 1,163 m, max depth 49 m.
Dates as given on the map: 2011-01 - 2012-02.
2011–2012 · Aktun-Hu
Alex Alvarez, Franco Attolini, Alberto Nava, Roberto Chavez, Gideon Liew, Jacob Mellor, Sam Meacham, Susan Bird, Christophe Le Maillot, Olmo Torres-Talamante
Survey with depth computer, compass, ScubaPro sonar, tape and knotted line.
Distance surveyed 1,163 m, max depth 49 m.
Dates as given on the map: 2011-01 - 2012-02.
2011 · Sac Actun
Connection with the Aktun Hu region ("2011 Connection"): 217,495 m, depth 107 m.
The map also marks the 1999, 2004 and 2007 connections.
2012 · Sac Actun
Sac Actun and Dos Ojos shown as one system: length 303,357 m, depth 125 m (October 2012).
August 2012 · Sac Actun
Don Arburn, Gill Ediger, Aida Ferreira, Devra Heyer, Carrie Hutchins, Pat Kambesis, Chris Lloyd, Rene Rogers Ohms, Bev Shade, Peter Sprouse, Terri Sprouse, Germán Yáñez Mendoza, Jacinto Vela
Suunto and laser rangefinder survey of the Pet Cemetery area.
September 2015 · Sac Actun
Dombrowski, Douglas Franquemont, Bil Phillips
January 2018 · Sac Actun
Robert Schmittner
First underwater connection with Dos Ojos, found by the Gran Acuífero Maya project (GAM). The two systems, joined through a dry passage since 2012, became the longest known flooded cave: 347 km.
Nearby caves#
- Ich Balam · 0.4 km · Aktun-Hu system
- Tak Be Ha · 0.4 km · Dos Ojos system
- Colapse Cenote · 0.5 km · Sac Actun system
- Oasis · 0.5 km · Outland system
- Le Colapse Turn · 0.6 km · Dos Ojos system
- La Virgen · 0.6 km · Outland system